Skip to content

Eulogy for a good Judge

March 14, 2012

I don’t normally write about individual judges on my blog but the unexpected loss of Judith Goodin can not go unnoticed.    She was well-respected and from all reports a good and honest judge of dogs. I hardly ever had the opportunity to show to her, but her skill and knowledge as a judge is not what made her a special person, it was neither that or her style or her excellent footwear.  What made her special was her kindness.

I have been lucky in that my 1st show dog was sold to me by some wonderful people Linda and Kevin Flynn who are my dear friends and mentors still.  I was lucky that they trusted me enough to send me a pick bitch from a lovely litter.  That pick bitch became my beautiful Windy, Ch Keltic’s Winter Solstice, CGC.   They sent her across the country to a newbie Novice and trusted that I’d do right by her and I tried.  She placed at the GSPCA nationals and I had managed to put single points on her but could just not get to Winner’s Bitch in major competition.  I had begun to worry that my lovely girl, oh so worthy was being held back by her not so worthy handler.  I was to the point of giving up and handing her off to someone with skill.  The Flynn’s had confidence in me but they were two time zones away and I was flaying.  Then along came Judy.

I spent a lot of time stewarding in my early days (still do when I have time) and after another disappointing day in the ring I was assigned to Judy’s ring.  What a lovely lady, kind to the dogs and handlers, pleasant and friendly to her steward, had great shoes.  Instead of doing her own thing during breaks she took the time to chat with me and ask about my breed.  Aww, a sporting dog person, how had I done, etc.  I told her how I had a lovely girl but I felt like as a novice I was getting in her way.  She made a kind remark and had to go back to judging.  When the lunch break came and the arena cleared out she looked around furtively and asked me if my girl was near by and if she was go and get her.  She was and I did.  Judy put me thru my paces in the ring, had me stack, gait, set up.  When she was done she put her hand on my shoulder and told me that I was doing a fine job and to just keep doing what I was doing and Windy would be a Champion before I knew it.    Then she went off for her much shorter lunch break.

Of course Windy did go on to finish owner handled and have a lovely litter and I went on to other doggy endeavors.  I have often wondered if Judith Goodin had not take that time to instill confidence in a novice handler would I have continued? 

But I did continue and to this day I try to remember her kindness, I try to make the effort to help new people to the sport, to give back and to be a force for good. 

To the people who loved her, your loss is devastating and there are no words of comfort I can give but know that she made a difference and may her kindness be remembered and paid forward.

2 Comments leave one →
  1. March 14, 2012 11:08 pm

    Judith Goodwin was the first Judge I ever showed to. I was a nervous wreck and blurted out to her that this was my first show dog and my first show when I had my Cardigan on the table. She smiled at me and said just have fun, and we did. We won our class and went on to winners dog. Imagine my glee when she walked to the end of the line and pointed at me. She smiled and said….”i’m giving you the points, do you know what that menas”, I told that I did. She took the time to give ma few hints when after we posed for our winner’s picture and I was hooked on dog showing for god. Everytime I showed to her, she always seemed to enjoy Judging. Such a loss….

  2. melinda johnson permalink
    March 20, 2012 4:01 am

    Mrs. Goodwin recently judged at the Santa Clara County shows. I was very impressed
    by her thoroughness and attentiveness she gave to each dog she examined. I saw her
    take a few minutes at the end to give a few suggestions to a novice presenter. She
    was an excellent representation of what a judge should be and will be a true loss to
    the sport of dogs.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: